When it comes to choosing a keyboard switch, there are various factors to consider, including typing experience, tactile feedback, and, of course, noise levels. Mechanical keyboards have gained immense popularity among typists and gamers due to their tactile feel and audible feedback. Among the many types of mechanical switches, the brown switch is often compared to membrane switches in terms of sound. In this article, we will explore whether the brown switch is indeed louder than a membrane switch.
Mechanical Keyboards Overview
Mechanical keyboards are known for their distinct key switches that use individual mechanical components for each key. These switches provide a tactile bump and an audible click sound when a key is pressed. The most common types of mechanical switches are Cherry MX, with brown switches being one of the variants.
Brown Switch Characteristics
Brown switches are a popular choice among typists who want a tactile feel without the loud clicky sound found in other mechanical switches like blue switches. They offer a gentle tactile bump without an audible click, making them suitable for both typing and gaming.
Membrane Keyboards Overview
In contrast to mechanical keyboards, membrane keyboards use a different mechanism. They have a rubber dome beneath the keys, which makes contact with a circuit board when a key is pressed. Membrane keyboards are known for their quiet operation but lack the tactile feel of mechanical switches.
Membrane Switch Characteristics
Membrane switches are often preferred in quiet environments, such as offices, due to their minimal noise production. They provide a soft and silent keystroke, making them a suitable choice for those who don't want to disturb others.
Sound Levels of Brown Switches
Brown switches are known for their relatively low noise levels compared to other mechanical switches like blue switches. The absence of an audible click makes them quieter, but they still produce a subtle typing sound due to keypress actuation.
Sound Levels of Membrane Switches
Membrane switches are famous for their silent operation. When a key is pressed on a membrane keyboard, the rubber dome absorbs the impact, resulting in minimal noise. This quietness makes membrane keyboards an excellent choice for noise-sensitive environments.
Typing Technique
The noise produced by both brown and membrane switches can vary depending on the typist's technique. Typing forcefully can make any keyboard switch louder, while typing gently can minimize noise.
Keyboard Construction
The overall design and build quality of the keyboard can also affect noise levels. A well-constructed mechanical keyboard with proper dampening can reduce the noise of brown switches.
In conclusion, whether a brown switch is louder than a membrane switch depends on various factors. Brown switches are quieter compared to clicky mechanical switches like blue switches but are not as silent as membrane switches. The choice between the two should be based on personal preference and the environment in which the keyboard will be used.
Are brown switches good for gaming?
Brown switches are suitable for gaming due to their tactile feedback, but they are not the quietest option available.
Can I make my brown switch keyboard quieter?
Yes, you can dampen the noise of brown switches by using dampening rings or O-rings.
Are membrane switches less durable than mechanical switches?
Generally, mechanical switches tend to be more durable than membrane switches, but it also depends on the specific keyboard and usage.
Do membrane keyboards provide tactile feedback?
Membrane keyboards do not offer the same level of tactile feedback as mechanical keyboards.
Is it possible to have a combination of brown switches and membrane switches on a single keyboard?
Some keyboards offer hybrid layouts, allowing you to have both brown switches and membrane switches, giving you the best of both worlds.
PREV
English
français
Deutsch
Español
italiano
português
dansk
Suomi
Polska
Svenska
Nederland